Signature & Custom Cakes

Here at Rosie’s, we’re happy to make the perfect cake for any occasion. From weddings to professional events and birthday parties and everything in between, we’re here to help ‘cake’ your day.

Rosie’s Signature Cake Flavors

– Serving Up a Little Taste of Home –

6″ (serves 6-10): $65 |  8″ (serves 16-20): $95

Made from scratch and decorated with love, our cake flavors and designs are guaranteed to please. From Grandma’s own chocolate layer cake recipe to our freshly made carrot cake and our new specialty cake flavors, our sweet selection is sure to match any occasion.

Learn more about our cake flavor selection below or give us a call to see what we can make for you!

Brandy Old Fashioned

Vanilla cake flavored with brandy, orange, and cherry, topped with a maraschino cherry-infused Italian buttercream frosting. Garnished with orange slices and maraschino cherries.

Carrot Cake

Loaded with carrots, coconut, pineapple, walnuts, and cinnamon with cream cheese frosting. Garnished with chopped walnuts. 

Lemon Raspberry

Zesty lemon cake with a raspberry buttercream frosting and white chocolate drip.

Mint Grasshopper

Chocolate cake with a mint cream cheese buttercream frosting and chocolate drip. Garnished with crushed Andes mints.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse

Peanut butter cream cheese and chocolate mousse cake with an Oreo cookie and chocolate crumble base. Topped with a rich chocolate ganache.

Oreo Explosion

Decadent chocolate cake with an Oreo cookie buttercream frosting and chocolate drip. Garnished with Oreo cookies.

Brandy Old Fashioned

Vanilla cake flavored with brandy, orange, and cherry, topped with a maraschino cherry-infused Italian buttercream frosting. Garnished with orange slices and maraschino cherries.

Mint Grasshopper

Chocolate cake with a mint cream cheese buttercream frosting and chocolate drip. Garnished with crushed Andes mints.

Carrot Cake

Loaded with carrots, coconut, pineapple, walnuts, and cinnamon with cream cheese frosting. Garnished with chopped walnuts.

Chocolate PB Mousse

Peanut butter cream cheese and chocolate mousse cake with an Oreo cookie and chocolate crumble base. Topped with a rich chocolate ganache.

Lemon Raspberry

Zesty lemon cake with a raspberry buttercream frosting and white chocolate drip.

Oreo Explosion

Decadent chocolate cake with an Oreo cookie buttercream frosting and chocolate drip. Garnished with Oreo cookies.

Custom Cakes

– Let Us Help You Celebrate Your Way –

Let your dessert imagination run wild! We’re happy to work with you to create a custom cake perfect for your occasion or event.

When designing a custom cake, we will work with you to determine the perfect style and flavor to fit your occasion. From cupcakes for your loved one’s birthday to the four-tiered wedding cake of your dreams, this custom creation promises to be the cherry on top of any celebration. All custom creations start at $200. Interested in designing a custom cake? Here is what to expect:

Step 1: Determine Serving Size

Knowing how many people are going to enjoy your cake will help determine the size and style. Looking for a custom wedding cake to serve 150? Then a cake with multiple tiers should do the trick! Hosting an intimate birthday party? Cupcakes might be a good pick for each guest to enjoy.

Step 2: Pick Your Flavor

At Rosie’s, we love to experiment with flavor combinations. That’s why with all custom cakes, you have the ability to work with one of our bakers to select the base flavor of your cake as well as the frosting style and flavor. Looking to add more than one flavor? No problem! Just let our bakers know and they will include it in your custom quote. Let your imagination run wild!

Step 3: Design Consultation

Our team of bakers is ready to design a creation that is a representation of your unique style and event. The more you can tell us about the event and how you are looking to celebrate, the better our team can help you create the cake of your dreams!

Step 4: Create A Custom Quote

After we have a better idea of how many people you are looking to serve, when the cake is going to be enjoyed, how many flavors you would like to include, and what kind of design you would like to see, our team will create a custom quote. All custom cakes begin at $200.

Order Your Custom Cake

Custom Wedding Cakes

– To help celebrate your big day –

Nothing makes us more excited than helping our clients celebrate their big day. We would be honored to be a part of your celebration and create memories that will last for years to come. 

Check out a few of our custom creations over the years below. 

Looking for a custom cake to satisfy your sweet tooth or celebrate your big day?

Fill out our custom order form and we’ll be in touch!

Order Your Custom Cake

Start Your Custom Order

Helping Create Lasting Memories

Delicious treats from Rosie’s have been a part of all our big life events from our wonderful wedding cake to our son’s first birthday cake. Coz and her crew do an amazing job to make memorable and flavorful desserts! They even make delicious caramel apple pies for all my clients! I can’t say enough good things about this awesome local bakery and their kind-hearted staff!

– Jennifer B.

I absolutely loved our cheesecake wedding cake frosted in buttercream. Coz is very personable, and makes sure that the details are in place so you can enjoy your day! She uses quality ingredients and turns out a delicious product.

– Jodie S.

Coz and her team at Rosie’s scored a touchdown with my wedding cake for my Green Bay Packers themed wedding back in 2016! Our meeting with her was super easy and she was completely open to my creative ideas meshing with her design and construction of my unique idea. We were able to taste many different flavors of cake and different combinations of frostings and fillings, so I had just what I wanted. The price was more than reasonable and the cake was delivered and set-up without me having to worry about it at all. So many of my wedding guests commented on how amazing the cake looked and how incredibly delicious it was! What a memorable cake Rosie’s created for us! Go Pack, Go!

– Jamie B.

We had the most delightfully decorated, deliciously decadent vegan chocolate wedding cake for our special day thanks to a little help from our friends and Rosie’s Coffee Bar and Bakery. We couldn’t have asked for a more perfect cake to celebrate our special day. Thank you!

– Olivia R. 

Coz and Rosie’s Coffee Bar & Bakery Staff were so amazing throughout the process of our wedding dessert selections. Working with Rosie’s was painless. Coz was easy to communicate with via phone and email. She was so accommodating and answered the many questions I had. We had originally planned to make a small cake and 6 flavors of mini cookies. I had no idea what to expect for taste testing but we told her what flavors we were looking for and they created all of them for the testing with a couple of extra ideas, along with a couple of cake, filling, and frosting flavors. We were plenty full of sweets when we left and we had leftovers too. I liked that Coz walked away so we could talk freely about the flavors as we enjoyed them, I thought that was a nice touch.

With COVID, things changed 2 weeks prior to the date of our wedding. Coz was accommodating once again, as we changed our order to add a second small cake and skip the cookies until next year when we plan to celebrate with all our friends and family. She was quick to assure me it would work perfectly and it did. The cake was delicious and moist and we had leftovers to enjoy afterward. She arranged our topper and flowers beautifully. I was so happy to see it all laid out. I’ve been to Rosie’s several times and I have never been disappointed. Great staff, excellent baked goods, and fabulous food. Thank you Coz and Staff for giving me one less thing to worry about on our big day!

– Trixy L.

Coz made my wedding cake way back in 1991! I could not have asked for a more amazing cake. It was beyond beautiful and absolutely delicious! I would recommend Coz and her team any day!! Thank you Coz!

– Stacy P.

Get in Touch

Contact Us

Follow Us